About Us

Over 50 Years of Trusted Coverage in Girard, Sebring, and Beloit

For more than 50 years, HHH/Neilson Insurance Agency has helped families and businesses throughout Girard, Sebring, and Beloit, Ohio find insurance that actually fits their lives, not a one-size-fits-all policy pulled from a national call center. What started as two locally rooted agencies grew into a single trusted name because our neighbors kept coming back, and their friends and family kept showing up right behind them.

Coverage That Fits, Not Coverage That’s Convenient

We believe affordable insurance and thorough insurance are not opposites; they go hand in hand when a policy is actually built around the person holding it. Rather than starting with the cheapest option and hoping it is enough, we start by understanding what you own, what you drive, and what you cannot afford to lose, then we tailor auto, home, business, farm, and life insurance coverage to match, backed by carrier relationships built over five decades in this community.

A Team That Knows Your Name, Not Just Your Policy Number

HHH/Neilson Insurance Agency is led by President Robert Warren, supported by a team that includes Lecia Cox and Kevin McBride handling day-to-day account service, and licensed agent Taralynn Rouse working directly with clients on new and existing policies. We offer a full range of personal and commercial coverage, including auto, homeowners, renters, condo, manufactured home, flood, motorcycle, recreational vehicle, and watercraft insurance for individuals and families, alongside business owners policies, commercial auto, contractors, farm, and general liability coverage for local business owners.

Rooted in Girard, Sebring, and Beloit, Not Just Serving It

With offices in both Girard and Sebring, HHH/Neilson Insurance Agency is positioned to serve this entire corner of Ohio without asking clients to drive across the state for a face-to-face conversation. We answer our own phones, we know the roads our clients drive and the homes they are protecting, and we would rather spend ten extra minutes explaining a coverage gap than let a client find out about it after a claim. Call us at 330-545-5406 (Girard) or 330-938-2084 (Sebring), or stop by either office, we invite you to experience the best customer service in the area for yourself.